1st GG Clan Tourney (WINNER: Anonymous Clan) [Concluded]

[amoffett11]

amoffett11
Diamond League
Status: single

Rule 5: if the winner loses the link, he ends up forfeiting? That seems strange. Here's an interesting scenario: player A beats Player B. player A loses the link. player A says to be B 'hey, be a good sport and put the link up'. Player B, who's a bit of a douche, says no. Then player A comes on the forum and says "hey, Player B won the game, but he lost the link, so I guess I win because he forfeits'. How can player B prove him wrong, unless he brings forward the link showing that he lost? Just a thought.

Rule 10: this could take awhile, unless the two teams clan leaders can find a time to bang it out simultaneously. I'm just thinking if some people post on the forums once or twice a day, it there's 20 matches per matchup, that could take 20 odd days just to set the matches.

Also, are there any rules concerning how often each team member has to play? By my count, there are 20 1v1s and 4 2v2s, which is 28 slots per team. If youre looking at 11+ players per team, do you have to use everyone at least twice? At most three times?

For the AvE team match, this isn't going to start until the rest of the matches have finished? This seems like out of all the matches will be the real time killer (the turn limit is 3 times as long), and I would think you'd want to start it earlier. If each team is P1 once, I wouldn't think it'd be a big deal to choose the P1s randomly, or let the team with the pick of the first player in the whole back and forth thing not get first pick at the map.

The only thing I don't like is that players can post screenshots and ask for advice for each individual game. I would prefer if the individual games were played on their own. I guess there's no way to ensure this, but each clan would be on the honour system I guess. I wouldn't like it if some clan had to face Poweewee 20 times or Mag!cguy 20 times. Let each clan member play for themselves, otherwise really what's the point of this thing?

I'm not trying to be nitpicky, just posting some thoughts. I really want this tournament to succeed.