Which Maps to Retire?

[poweewee]

(02-05-2013 01:06 PM)garcia1000 Wrote:  Here are reasons I don't want to see various maps in league games:

1) Peekaboo. Oh my god, Scallywags vs Scallywags, 9000 turn games, that's terrible regardless of how good the map is otherwise.

2) Reaper. This map favours Mobi just tooooooooo much. It's too unfair. Even more unfair than Scallywags on Sharkfood Island.

3) Foundry. This map has significant First Turn Advantage.

This is exactly how I feel. However, I'm trying to think that, if for instance, there were no Mobis involved, Reaper could actually be a really fun map. If there were no Scallies involved, Peekaboo is also pretty nice.

What if (a big if) if you played Adorables, then you would have less chance of playing on Reaper than if you played any other race? If you played Scallies, you would have less chance of being sent to Peekaboo than as any other race?

I'm not entirely sure that's possible; but I just feel that if you remove those races from those maps, they are still actually pretty fun to play on.

I'm leaning towards not removing any maps at all.