OMC Evaluation Thread

[Piko]

So - we have got general OMC topic, but I think it's good to make a topic only for comments of maps. To people reading it: please take a look on fanmade maps: to do it You don't need to make account, download anything etc. - You can just open it with Your browser on any device. To rate them, You too don't need anything special - just do one click/tap. And writing a little comment don't cost much of time, too.

Ok, well:

Invocation
- Good placement of units, bases, spawns and wit spaces (+1.5 star)
- Looks not bad (+0.5)
- P1 can hit P2 base using runner at turn 2 - P2 can't prevent it (-0.5)
- Too simple idea - only one passage, with is 3 hexes wide (-1)
Rate: 3.5

Chains Of Command
#It should be blue+green vs red+yellow, not b+r vs g+y
#Buffers aren't placed correctly (symmetrically)
- Games on this map need a bit of teamwork (+0.5)
- A good placement of wit spaces - it's possible to attack unit standing on it from two tiles (+0.5)
- All starting units are healers (-0.5)
- Good places for snipers near bases - it's more worth to camp (-0.5)
Rate: 3.0

Killing Corridor
#Correct strawberres - aren't symmetrical
- Map need a special strategy to play on (+1)
- Impossible to get any wit point at turn 1 (-0.5)
- Wit points are in snipers' range - everything weaker than 4hp die instantly (-0.5)
- It's easy to camp here - one unit between strawberries + sniper on the flank (-1)
Rate: 2.0

---

My maps: http://omc.harti.us/author/piko/
Especially need comments about Beach 341 - an attempt to make an assymetrial (but playable) map.