Poll: Which maps (if any) should be retired?

ElPared · 02-23-2013, 05:34 AM

(02-22-2013 11:55 AM)connor34911 Wrote:
(02-22-2013 11:45 AM)harvarnold Wrote: ^send me an invite as p1

I'm open to a friendly as P2 on SP too. The key is defending the sniper.

that's probably what's making things so difficult. He baited me into sniping a soldier early on which put my sniper in range of runner shenanigans

blah...

I have 20 games going right now, but I might do some friendlies when they're finished

jaxxinjr · (This post was last modified: 03-01-2013 04:48 PM by jaxxinjr.)

Probably already mentioned, but my vote is to NOT put this to a vote. The most imbalanced maps should be retired, plain and simple. This should be data-driven, not democratic.

Another way to fix imbalanced map issues is to get rid of the HUGE P1 advantage of getting to choose the map and team. Make it random for both. I'm tired of getting so many Adorable/Reaper match ups!! And because of that, I'm shocked Reaper didn't get many votes. It's much more imbalanced than SFI.

bobolynx · 03-02-2013, 03:50 PM

I think this question shouldn't be posed to the general public as top players know a lot more about what actually turns out fair. When I voted on this like two weeks (or something) ago I didn't realize how much of an fta advantage there was on foundry. It should either be open to only masters and supertitans, or the votes should be changeable with a proper presentation of the arguments for each.

Derr furlong · 03-03-2013, 06:32 AM

I initially voted for foundry, but since its gotten so much attention for the fta, players including myself have been adjusting strategies as p2 and and as a result I've been winning more than half of my foundry games

Poll: Which maps (if any) should be retired? This poll is closed.
Sharkfood Island	68	11.91%
Long Nine	29	5.08%
Glitch	22	3.85%
Foundry	74	12.96%
Sweetie Plains	35	6.13%
Peekaboo	84	14.71%
Reaper	36	6.30%
Thorn Gulley	33	5.78%
Don't remove any maps!	190	33.27%
Total	571 vote(s)	100%